|
HATTIE: Hi, and
welcome to SMALL BUSINESS SCHOOL.
Grab a pencil.
You'll want to take notes if you're interested in growing a business or even
starting one. I'm Hattie Bryant. From Madison, Wisconsin, a place with plenty
of cyclists on the roads, comes this program about growing a business that had
become stale. If you want to take your bike with you, you need a rack. That's
what Graber Products builds.
Most of our 30
minutes every week is spent in our Master Class. We believe the highest level
of learning takes place in a mentoring relationship, not a formal classroom,
and a master class is a way for us to be mentored. A master class is led by a
person with experience, not simply book knowledge. Join Chris and Sara Fortune
in the small business Master Class.
(Voiceover) What a
perfect day. What a beautiful place. Cyclists from all over the world come to
Wisconsin to experience hundreds of miles of paved roads, not only in the city
but in the country, too, free from traffic. In addition to the smooth country
roads, Wisconsin offers well-connected bike trails that offer some of the most
scenic, and historical, views in the state.
If you have a bike,
you have to have a rack. Graber Products makes some of the world's best racks
right here in Madison, Wisconsin. |

1
Invent the new products before a competitor can.
Employee #1: We're
going to take your new receiver hitch mount, slide it into the receiver, like
so. Now, were ready to take the bike and set it up on the rack, all the
way to the back. Set the bike in the cradles of the Bat Wing
HATTIE: All
right. Employee #1: ...slide it forward so you've got the saddles of your wing
supporting your seat tube and the other saddle supporting the top tube. Take
the strap across the top, nice and tight.
HATTIE: This is a
very easy little notch. It's like a hook and eye system, sort of. Very nice.
Very simple.
Employee #1: Now
you've got support across the top so the bike doesn't bounce. You also have
support across the bottom, so it doesnt sway.
CHRIS FORTUNE
(Owner, Graber Products, Madison, Wisconsin): Consumers want a product that's
user-friendly, and so do our dealers. This drives us to supply products that
are very user-friendly. You know, the bicycle industry is a booming industry.
It's a great family sport, it's a low-cost recreation. People love taking their
bikes on vacation and go out and ride as a family. And we want to provide them
the transportation system to get them where they want to go, safely and
securely.
Whenever we develop
product, there are three musts, and it's very simple and very basic. The racks
must stay on the car, the bikes must stay on the rack (we don't want to scratch
or mar the car), and it's critical to get the people where they are going,
safely and securely. We do a pretty good job of that
our warranty rate
is less than one-quarter of a percent. |
| Review the study guide |

You can buy and old business but you don't have
to be stuck with old images
2
HATTIE: (Voiceover)
Sara and Chris Fortune bought the company in 1989 when it had 24 employees and
$3.3 million in sales. Today, they employ 60 people and have tripled the sales.
SARA FORTUNE
(Owner, Graber Products): I always knew that he'd work hard. He put himself
through college. He worked while we were engaged. He worked nights,
student-taught and then got his studying done. He was just the kind of guy that
always worked. I don't really think I've ever had any real doubts in where he
wanted to go. Every job he took on, he succeeded.
CHRIS: When we
looked at businesses to buy, we had a scope of what we wanted and what we
didn't want. I really felt that I was driven to develop a product or get into a
situation where we had an opportunity to develop a brand. I knew I didn't want
to get into the retail environment. And I didn't want to stay in distribution
because I didn't feel that you had control of your own destiny. I think there's
tremendous value in developing a brand, and when we looked at Graber as a
company, we felt they had a great reputation in the marketplace. We visited
stores and did some market research, talking to the dealers to get a feel for
what was going on.
And the market was
expanding. They had some tremendous opportunity if they had just focused on the
resources that they had, and they didn't do that. The two gentlemen—one
was 68 and the other one was 75, wanted to move on with their lives. They were
trying to maximize their balance sheet and their profitability at the risk of
the future of the business. There are three types of people and three types of
companies: There are companies that wonder what's happening, companies that
watch what's happening and companies that make things happen.
And these gentlemen
were wondering and watching what was going on out there. They had a good
nucleus of people when we bought the business. They had a good reputation in
the marketplace as being honest and honorable people. That was important to us.
You know, part of our business culture states that we want to be honest and do
the right thing in the way we approach our business and our customers. And they
had that going for them.
HATTIE: So you
didn't have to undo...
CHRIS: Correct. But
the image of Graber in the marketplace was more of a nuts and bolt
manufacturer. From a development and design standpoint, things had leapfrogged
where Graber was positioned in the market. Whenever you have competition
obsolete your own product, you're in a big danger zone, and that's what was
happening to them.
HATTIE: Did you
start with a bank loan?
CHRIS: Yes.
HATTIE: OK. And did
you get your venture capital from one bank?
CHRIS: Yes, it was
from the Associated Bank, and they're great people. You know, business is very
cyclical, and it isn't always growth and prosperity. You have some rough times
along the way, and it's very important to find someone that's willing to work
through the good and the bad times with you. We found somebody.
|
| Review the study guide |

Necessity should
be the mother of invention
3
HATTIE: What are
your top business issues?
SARA: Innovation.
Product development. Go beyond what is out in the market--don't copy somebody
else. Innovation builds market recognition.
HATTIE: So now,
Bob, explain to me what this is.
(Voiceover)
Everyone at Graber talks about innovation. Chris's dad invented the Bike Bank,
which Graber is selling worldwide.
BOB FORTUNE (Chris
Fortune's father): You open the lid like this, and place your helmet, your
fanny pack or whatever gear you have, into the locker and lock it.
HATTIE: So how did
you think of this?
BOB: Well, I read
an article in The Wall Street Journal about the cyclists starting to commute.
The problem was that when they got to their destinations, they had no place to
store their personal belongings, and they were concerned about the bike. This
locks the bike and secures your personal things.
HATTIE: What is it
like to have your dad around this place?
CHRIS: It's just
great to have him around. You know, he's dedicated and committed to getting it
done, and it's just a pleasure to have him around. My dad's my best friend, and
it couldn't be any better than that.
BOB: You couldn't
ask for much better than that, could you?
CHRIS: This is
Brian Butchen. Brian has been with us 17 years. He is an extremely talented
toolmaker.
HATTIE: Are you
constantly innovating?
BRIAN BUTCHEN
(Employee): Yes, we're constantly innovating. You have to be.
HATTIE: (Voiceover)
Chris and Sara took advantage of the University of Wisconsin Stouts
Manufacturing Technology Transfer program to help improve efficiency.
CHRIS: And one of
the elements that they focused on was cellular manufacturing. With cellular
manufacturing, quick-change tooling is a very important aspect. For example, in
our business each time you touch a part, it costs about 5 cents. So Brian
developed a tool that when the press came down and hit the part, instead of
hitting it twice, it only hit it once.
BRIAN
(demonstrating process): This way, we're taking a raw tube (you can see it's
not formed or punched in any shape or manner) It takes it from the round tube,
forms this U-shape into it to fit into the receiver of the hitch.
Unidentified
Employee #2: And basically, I just bent the tube down in there.
BRIAN: Then you go
into the next stage, poke the tube sideways, and it punches the holes.
HATTIE: And you
built the tool that does that?
CHRIS: Right. Brian
built the tool. Cellular manufacturing has done several things for us. One,
it's improved the quality of the parts because we have a much smaller
production run. Two, it's reduced our work in process inventory, improving our
efficiency by almost 25 percent.
HATTIE: How is that
different from an assembly line?
CHRIS: Well, it's
very similar to an assembly line. However, some assembly lines are set up to
feed parts that have been processed in an operation outside the assembly line,
whether that be in an assembly line set up in a different part of the company
or parts that have been brought in from outside of the company. With the
cellular manufacturing, everything is processed right here.
|
| Review the study guide |

Limit the number of suppliers to increase
influence.
4
CHRIS: We approach
business a little differently. We try and limit our number of vendors. We have
one major tubing vendor with whom we have formed a true partnership. We
dont go back and forth, saying `Hey, we need a cheaper price here or we
need this or that.' We sit down and develop a strategy with them, and we're
honorable in the commitments we make to them.
HATTIE: So rather
than having three or four suppliers on that one product who are always
competing and never knowing if they're going to get the business or not, you
selected one and said, `We're committed.'
CHRIS: We're
committed. And they're sharing technology with us, too. We send engineers to
work with them to try and get an understanding of how we can do our business
better or perform manufacturing at a higher level. We've really adopted a
win-win philosophy here. In my younger years as a manager, I wasn't always that
way. You know, I thought you had to go out and win at all costs. However, I
realized that didn't necessarily produce a long-term gain. I made some mistakes
along the way that have helped me make better decisions in my business.
HATTIE: Oh, in your
old age of 44, you've mellowed out?
CHRIS: Well, I was
a branch manager at 30 years old, running a $3 million or $4 million company.
And, you know, you develop a win-at-all-costs attitude. Ive found that's
a very short-term approach to life and business. Over time, you really hone
your approach to life.
I have a great
mentor, my wife's father, Phil Hendrickson. It's great to have somebody like
him to guide you and influence your life and give you certain goals and values
to run a business.
HATTIE: Was he a
small business owner?
CHRIS: He was a
business owner and a manager of a business. He took a business from $500,000 to
$150 million. I watched him do that. When we bought our business eight years
ago, I asked him to be on our board. He is really the person I go to for
advice. He's my mentor. It's great to have somebody like that, someone who has
been there, done that; someone you can trust.
HATTIE: How did you
develop your board?
CHRIS: We selected
people that we knew. Our banker, Bob Atwell, is on the board. He is a
tremendous resource. He understands our business and we have a very honest and
open relationship. Our corporate attorney is on the board, as well as my father
and Sara's father. We also have somebody that was the president of a bicycle
company. He is a great adviser. Whether you have a board or you have people
around that you can use as a resource to validate what you're trying to get
done, it is important to have input from people you know and trust.
HATTIE: Or to say,
`Well, Chris, you're crazy.' Has the board ever said to you, `Oh, my gosh,
don't do that'?
CHRIS: Yes. We were
looking at buying another company, and we went through the whole analysis. The
board didn't feel that the timing was right and so we listened...
HATTIE: And you
respected that.
CHRIS: Absolutely.
Not that I didn't feel that there was great value or opportunity, but you have
a board for a reason. You'd better listen to these people.
SARA: Chris goes
out and visits the dealers. You know, here's the president of the company, he
goes out to the dealer and talks to them. I bet he knows 90 percent of the
people he's met anywhere in the industry. He remembers their names. He focuses
on the people all the time. For example, this spring Chris brought in six of
the top dealers for a two-day session at our family cottage in Door County.
They had good time
to blend and build the relationships, which I think Chris is really strong at,
but Chris also asked them to focus in on what the user is going to want. Chris
asked them, `What are you missing in your product line that we can accomplish
for you?' The dealers were asked to list the priorities of what we have and
what they want to see. Their input was sought on where we should go. We use
their input in product development. Their input guides us in making the product
they want; the product they want to sell.
HATTIE: And out of
these six people, only two of them at that time were your customers.
SARA: Yes, and the
other four were accounts that we didn't have. Just within the last few months,
that's how long it took, the four dealers who had not been selling our products
said, `We'll take your product. We value what you're doing.' And that is
relationship building. Chris is really outstanding at the relationship building
in the industry. |
| Review the study guide |

Bankruptcy can be the easy decision.
5
HATTIE: What do you
think it takes internally to be able to shoulder the risk of business?
CHRIS: I think a
lot of it is attitude, a "never-give-up" attitude. And it's just keeping your
head down and driving through the hard times, because if you look up, you may
lose your head. As a business owner, for you to be successful, the biggest
thing is to never give up -- never, ever give up.
SARA: When we
bought the business, we were hit with a patent infringement. Chris went to the
previous owners and said, `We got this. It's not settled. We feel like it came
before the purchase.' And they settled easily. It was all calm. We thought it
was gone. Business thrived, we developed. We added a new product to get our
name back out into the market, and it did very well. And then, about 18 months
later, we got another letter saying we were infringing. And we thought it had
all been settled, because it was on the existing patent.
And what I've
learned in that short time--well, it ended up being about four months--I
learned that this bigger company knew exactly what they were doing. We went to
trial in March. It was a simple, tiny part of a patent. We went to a jury
trial. Everything that we said--what we were told wouldn't happen, did happen.
In the end, we lost 10 times more than we thought and had to cease to produce
in the spring. I really believe the big company wanted us out. They saw us at
that time as a challenge to them, and they thought, `Let's snuff these guys out
now so we don't have to deal with them in the future.' And the bankruptcy issue
was brought up.
HATTIE: So you lost
$1 million in that scenario.
SARA: Right.
HATTIE: And when
you lost $1 million and also had to shut production down, you said to
yourselves, `All right, what are our choices?'
SARA: Right.
HATTIE: And
bankruptcy was a legitimate choice.
SARA: And probably
the number one choice for the people around us, saying, `This is the way you'll
survive.' But that's also the relationship with the bank we had.
Chris--once again,
it's the value in Chris. He's a survivor, end of the story.
Chris and I sat
down and talked, and bankruptcy just wasn't an option. I mean, there's
something that grates wrong in it.
CHRIS: We looked at
bankruptcy, but we didn't feel that was morally or ethically the way to do it.
SARA: And the bank
also supported us and said, `OK, this is what we can do to help, this is what
we're going to require of you.' So we've been carefully watched. It was a bad
time for us not only in the money issues, but it was the moral issues. For me
especially, I was just dumfounded. I believed in people so strongly, and what
they were saying.
CHRIS: We've been
through the valley of death, and the way we've come through is our commitment
to get through it and our determination to get through it.
HATTIE: Were you
ever scared when you were in the valley? CHRIS: Sure. HATTIE: Did you ever
think, `Well, we may not have the wherewithal to pay...'
CHRIS: It was never
an option. We had to find a way to be successful and make this thing work.
HATTIE: (Voiceover)
In Sara and Chris, I see soft hearts and strong backs. What a combination. It's
obviously working.
The turnaround came
quickly. Something really exciting happened.
CHRIS: Saturn had
approached us in August of '95 and they were very interested in the Saris roof
rack system. We'd been working with them over the last two years, doing testing
and validating the program. They've chosen us, over the largest competitor in
the world, as a supplier for their roof rack. It was due to product innovation
and their willingness to work with a smaller company.
Employee #1: I
don't think I've seen a rack any easier than this to install on a vehicle.
Unidentified Woman:
Now will I have to adjust it each time I put it on? Employee #1: No.
CHRIS: (Voiceover)
We are the exclusive supplier of a detachable roof rack system for Saturn
today.
Employee #1: The
nice thing about the rack is that it is totally adjustable, so we can position
these legs wherever we want them. If you are behind a car carrying bikes on
real cheap racks, you will see the bikes and the rack are actually moving back
and forth as the car travels. This one won't do that because you've got support
in six different places.
HATTIE: (Voiceover)
Sara focuses on the people part.
SARA: I kind of
make sure they're OK, more on the personal side. I love to talk, so I'm out
there wondering what's going on with them, finding a lot of things out. There's
some employees that will come up and spend a lot of time with me, you know,
just talking, and I usually get a hint of the reason they're around.
HATTIE: Right.
Well--and don't you think that is part of the reason this is all working? SARA:
Right. I do. HATTIE: And that every employee here feels comfortable to come
tell you anything they want. |
| Review the study guide |
The
Lightbulb.
LB
HATTIE: The slogan
at Graber Products is `Make ourselves obsolete. Invent the new products before
a competitor can.'
By working with the
University of Wisconsin, Chris has tapped into the minds of an innovation and
manufacturing team that helps business owners streamline the production of new
ideas. He has given employees the tools and time to innovate, and he himself
focuses his own attention on innovation.
The day after we
were with Chris, he was on a plane to Italy to meet a designer.
When Chris and Sara
bought Graber, they bought a solid business with a good reputation, but the
sales were flat. The employees were dedicated, but the company needed fresh
energy to start growing again. The energy has come from Chris and Sara, but
also from the thrill of bringing new products to the marketplace. Before your
sales go flat, start innovating. |
| Review the study guide |

Make "Made in America" mean
quality.
6
(Voiceover) Just as
so much manufacturing has gone offshore, this business could have headed that
way, but Sara and Chris are determined to keep Graber alive and all-American.
CHRIS: Part of the
thing that drove me to pursue this business was that I saw so much
manufacturing going offshore. I just felt that there was a decline in America,
and that it was very important for us to re-establish our manufacturing base.
You know, you talk about the service industry and the retail industry, and I
really feel that we can build product domestically and compete internationally
with the right design and development, and we're doing that. Right now, we're
not only in the United States but we're in 20 countries internationally. And we
can do that. Two of our largest competitors, Yakima is down in Mexico now and
Thule is out of Europe, and we feel that we can compete with them.
SARA: It really
does take a survivor--that really describes Chris--and support from people
around you. I think Chris and I are really lucky because we give on both sides.
Sometimes it takes us awhile to figure that out, but we give on both sides. I'd
say most small business owners really give a lot of their lives to that
business to make it successful. And that's part of the risk.
CHRIS: It is really important as a business
leader to carry the torch and continually communicate your values to the
company, the vision of your company to your employees. You know a person by
the trail he leaves and the people they hang with, and it's very important.
|
| Review the study guide |
THE CLOSING OF THE SHOW
COMMENTS
OR QUESTIONS. We invite your comments and questions. Was the show
inspirational and/or educational? We hope this show is both!
Go to this show's other pages:Overview / Profile, case study,
video or home page. |
|